Skip to content
  1. Blog
  2. General

Unlimited Liability in a 5,000 Dollar Contract: When Risk Stops Making Sense

TL;DR: A small contract can carry unlimited liability when its indemnity clause sits outside the liability cap. A clear cap that names the indemnity keeps the risk in line with the fee. Once both sides agree the terms, you can send the same approved wording for signature from a reusable BoldSign template.

Picture a made-up example. A small software firm signs a 5,000 dollar yearly deal with a large client. Nobody reads the legal terms closely, because the deal is small and the clauses look standard.

A year later, an attacker breaks into the software and reaches client data. The client faces an inquiry and angry users. It then asks the firm to pay for everything under the indemnity clause.

The firm points to its liability cap. The cap never mentions the indemnity, so the protection is weaker than expected. On a 5,000 dollar deal, the firm now faces a claim with no clear ceiling.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. The rules differ by country, state and type of contract, so ask a lawyer about your own deal.

What does unlimited liability mean in a contract?

Unlimited liability means the contract sets no ceiling on what one party may have to pay. The claim can grow as large as the loss the law allows.

Think of renting a ladder for 20 dollars. You would accept paying for the ladder if you broke it. Paying for every loss anyone ever blames on the ladder, with no upper limit, is a different deal.

A contract works the same way. The fee is what you earn, and the liability terms say what you could lose.

How can a small contract carry unlimited liability?

Unlimited liability usually comes from an indemnity clause that sits outside the liability cap. The cap limits general claims, while the indemnity stays open.

An indemnity is a promise to cover the other side’s losses from certain events. Those losses often come from claims by third parties, and they can include:

  • legal defense costs
  • settlements and court awards
  • fines, where the law lets one party pass them on
  • the cost of dealing with affected customers

A limitation of liability clause sets the cap. Some drafts apply it to “all claims under this agreement”, while others carve the indemnity out. Read both clauses side by side and look for words like “except” or “notwithstanding”.

Why is unlimited liability hard to justify in a small deal?

A business prices each deal against the risk it takes on. Nobody can put a price on an open-ended claim, so the deal stops making commercial sense.

In our made-up example, the firm earns 5,000 dollars a year. One data breach claim could cost many times that, and nothing in the price covers it.

Insurance often fails to close the gap. Every policy has limits and exclusions, and some policies leave certain losses out. Any claim above your cover comes from your own cash.

For a startup, that can be the end of the business. One large claim can drain its reserves and scare off investors.

How do these risks end up in a contract?

Most unlimited liability is an oversight, not a choice. Teams reuse an old template, focus on price and treat the legal terms as routine.

The gap between the cap and the indemnity rarely shows while things go well. It shows when something goes wrong, and by then both sides have signed.

Our guide to contract risks to check before signing covers other clauses that often slip through.

What does the law say about limiting liability?

In many places, the law lets parties agree a limit on damages, with exceptions. The answer for your contract depends on its governing law and what it covers.

In the US, the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) covers contracts for the sale of goods. UCC section 2-719 lets a contract limit damages. It also says a limit on consequential damages fails when it is unconscionable, meaning grossly unfair.

UCC section 2-302 lets a court refuse to enforce an unconscionable clause, or limit how it applies. Software services, other contract types and other countries follow their own rules. Do not rely on a court to fix a bad clause later.

How do you check indemnity and liability terms before you sign?

Read the cap and the indemnity together, then ask for changes before you sign. These steps cover the checks a reviewer would make.

  1. Find the liability cap and note the amount and what it applies to.
  2. Find every indemnity and list the losses it covers.
  3. Check whether the cap names the indemnity or carves it out.
  4. Compare the largest possible claim with your insurance limits.
  5. Ask for the indemnity to sit under the cap, or a separate cap for it.

Some claims, such as fraud or willful misconduct, often stay outside the cap by agreement. Name each one, so neither side can stretch the list later.

Our guide to the cap on liability explains common cap structures and how to negotiate one.

How do you sign the final contract with BoldSign?

Upload the agreed contract, add each signer and send it for signature. We email each signer a link, and they can sign from any device.

Save the approved wording as a template, so the next deal starts from terms you have already checked. Every signed document comes with an audit trail that records each signer’s name, the time and their internet protocol (IP) address.

The US Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce (ESIGN) Act covers electronic contracts. It says a contract cannot lose its legal effect only because the parties signed it electronically.

How much does BoldSign cost for signing contracts?

The Essential plan is free and includes 2 templates. The Growth plan costs $5 per user a month, billed yearly, and includes 10 templates.

The Business plan costs $15 per user a month, billed yearly, with unlimited templates. The Premium plan costs $99 a month, billed yearly, for unlimited users and unlimited templates. Prices are in USD, and you can try BoldSign first with a 30-day free trial.

Ready to sign contracts with risk you can live with?

Balanced terms protect both sides, and a signed record keeps them on file. Here are three ways to start:

Frequently asked questions

What is unlimited liability in a contract?

It means the contract sets no ceiling on what one party may have to pay. A claim can then grow as large as the loss the law allows, however small the deal was.

Does a limitation of liability clause cover indemnity?

Only when the wording says so. Many drafts keep the cap and the indemnity in separate clauses, so check whether the cap names the indemnity or carves it out.

Is unlimited liability enforceable in a small contract?

Yes, when both parties agreed to it and the governing law has no rule against it. Contract size alone rarely changes that, which is why the wording matters before you sign.

Can a court strike down an unfair liability clause?

Yes, when the law that governs the contract allows it. In US sales of goods, a court can refuse to enforce a clause it finds unconscionable under UCC section 2-302.

What is a fair liability cap for a 5,000 dollar contract?

A common starting point is the fees paid over the last 12 months, which here is the contract value. That is a drafting habit, not a legal rule, so test it against your real risks.

Will my insurance pay for an indemnity claim?

Only up to your policy limits and within its terms. Read the exclusions, and ask your broker whether contractual indemnities and regulatory fines are covered.

Should I sign a contract with uncapped indemnity?

Think twice when the possible claim is far larger than the fee. Ask for the indemnity to sit under the cap, or narrow it to claims you can control.

Is a contract signed electronically legally binding?

Yes, when the parties agree to sign electronically and the record is kept. In the US, the ESIGN Act says a contract cannot be denied effect only because it was signed electronically.

Priscah Akech Okeyo

Priscah is a skilled and dedicated lawyer at Syncfusion with expertise in legal research, document drafting, and digital signature workflows. She supports legal operations with accuracy and compliance, contributes to BoldSign templates and educational blogs, and is passionate about digital transformation in law, including e-signature compliance and eIDAS, effectively bridging law and technology. Connect with her on LinkedIn.

More posts by Priscah Akech Okeyo
Get started

Sign up for your free trial today!

Start free trial
  • 30-day free trial
  • No credit card required