TL;DR: Consequential damages are the knock-on losses a breach causes, such as lost sales or missed deals, rather than the cost of fixing what failed. Many contracts exclude them because they are hard to predict and can grow far larger than the deal. Once the clause is agreed, you can send the final contract for signature with a full audit trail.
A logistics company signs a 500,000 dollar deal with a software vendor. During peak season, the system crashes.
Fixing the bug is the smaller problem. Missed shipments, lost customers and cancelled orders follow, and the company claims millions.
The vendor now faces a claim many times larger than the contract. Whether it has to pay depends on one clause: the exclusion of consequential damages.
This guide is general information, not legal advice. The rules differ by country, state and type of contract, so ask a lawyer before you rely on any clause.
What are consequential damages?
Consequential damages are losses a breach causes indirectly, through the injured party’s wider needs and plans. They sit on top of the direct cost of the breach.
Think of a power cut at home. The blown fuse is the direct damage. The spoiled food in the fridge and the work you could not finish are the consequential damages.
In US sales of goods, the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) gives a definition. UCC section 2-715(2) says a buyer’s consequential damages include two things.
The first is a loss from needs the seller had reason to know about when the contract was made. The buyer must also be unable to prevent it in a reasonable way.
The second is injury to a person or property that results from a breach of warranty.
What is the difference between direct and consequential damages?
Direct damages flow naturally from the breach itself. Consequential damages depend on your own situation, such as other deals that rely on the contract.
New York’s highest court put it this way in Bi-Economy Market v. Harleysville Insurance (2008).
General damages are “the natural and probable consequence of the breach”. Consequential damages “do not so directly flow from the breach” and are recoverable only in limited cases.
| Breach | Direct damages | Consequential damages |
|---|---|---|
| Software fails | Cost to fix or replace the system | Orders lost while it was down |
| Late delivery of parts | Extra cost to buy parts elsewhere | Penalties under your own customer contract |
| Faulty equipment | Repair or replacement cost | Damage the fault causes to other property |
What are common examples of consequential damages?
Most claims fall into a few familiar groups. Contracts often name them one by one in the exclusion clause.
- Lost profits or revenue from deals that depended on the contract.
- Lost customers or contracts after a failure.
- Damage to reputation or goodwill.
- Fines or penalties owed under other agreements.
- Lost or corrupted data and the cost of rebuilding it.
Whether each one counts as consequential depends on the facts and the governing law. A careful clause lists the losses it means, so nobody has to argue about the label later.
When can you recover consequential damages?
In many US courts, you can recover them when the loss was foreseeable when the contract was made. You also need to prove the amount with reasonable certainty.
In Bi-Economy, the court said the breaching party is liable for risks “foreseen or which should have been foreseen” at the time of contracting. Courts look at the nature, purpose and circumstances of the contract known to both sides.
The same opinion warns that proof “cannot be speculative or conjectural”. A claim for lost future profits needs figures based on known, reliable factors.
Why do contracts exclude consequential damages?
Contracts exclude them to keep risk in proportion to the value of the deal. The supplier then knows its worst case before it signs.
- Neither side can know every plan that depends on the contract.
- A small contract can trigger a claim many times its value.
- An exclusion avoids a later fight over what each side knew.
An exclusion often works alongside a cap on liability. The exclusion removes whole types of loss, and the cap limits what remains.
Is an exclusion of consequential damages enforceable?
Often, yes, when the clause is clear and the governing law allows it. The exact test depends on where you are and what the contract covers.
For US sales of goods, UCC section 2-719(3) says consequential damages may be limited or excluded unless the limit is unconscionable. Unconscionable means so one-sided that a court will not enforce it.
The same section treats a limit on personal injury damages for consumer goods as unconscionable at first sight. A limit on commercial loss is not treated that way. Service contracts and other countries follow their own rules.
What does the Bi-Economy case teach about exclusion wording?
Courts read an exclusion by its exact words. A clause that seems to exclude consequential losses may not stop a claim for consequential damages.
After a fire destroyed Bi-Economy’s meat market, its insurer paid only part of the claim. The insurer offered seven months of lost business income, though the policy covered twelve. The business never reopened.
The insurer pointed to policy terms excluding “consequential loss”. The court read those terms as covering losses from the fire, not damages for the insurer’s own breach.
The court held the claim for the collapse of the business could go ahead. Business interruption cover exists to keep a business running, so that loss was foreseeable.
How do you draft or negotiate a consequential damages exclusion?
Start with the losses your deal could really cause, then write a clause that names them. Work through these steps before you sign.
- List the worst losses each side could suffer, beyond the cost of fixing the breach.
- Decide which losses the exclusion covers, and name them, such as lost profits or lost data.
- Agree whether the exclusion applies to both parties or to one side.
- Agree the carve-outs, such as confidentiality breaches or claims your insurance already covers.
- Check that the clause fits your liability cap and your insurance limits.
Then read the whole contract for terms that pull against the exclusion. A broad indemnity can bring back the losses you meant to exclude. Our guide to unlimited liability in a small contract shows how that happens.
What should you watch out for in these clauses?
Most problems come from vague words or from clauses that contradict each other. Each one below has a simple fix.
- Using “indirect” or “consequential” without saying which losses you mean.
- Excluding losses but leaving damages for a breach open, or the reverse.
- Letting an indemnity or warranty clause override the exclusion.
- Agreeing to carve-outs so broad they swallow the exclusion.
A fixed sum agreed in advance is a separate tool with its own rules. Our guide to liquidated damages versus penalties covers when it holds up.
How do you sign the final contract with BoldSign?
Upload the agreed contract, add each signer and send it for signature. We email each signer a link, and they sign from any device.
We record an audit trail for every document, with each signer’s name, email, internet protocol (IP) address and device. The date and time of every action are logged too. Contracts you send often can live in a reusable template.
How much does BoldSign cost for signing contracts?
The Essential plan is free and includes 2 templates. The Growth plan costs $5 per user a month, billed yearly, and includes 10 templates.
The Business plan costs $15 per user a month, billed yearly, with unlimited templates. The Premium plan costs $99 a month, billed yearly, for unlimited users and unlimited templates. Prices are in USD.
Ready to put your next contract in writing?
A clear exclusion protects both sides, and a signed record keeps it on file. Here are three ways to start:
- Start a 30-day free trial of BoldSign and send your first contract.
- Book a demo to see how teams send and track agreements.
- Visit our support portal for help with any step.
Frequently asked questions
What are consequential damages in simple terms?
They are the knock-on losses a breach causes, beyond the cost of the breach itself. Lost sales after a system outage are a common example.
What is the difference between direct and consequential damages?
Direct damages flow naturally from the breach, such as the cost to repair or replace what failed. Consequential damages come from your own wider needs, such as orders you lose while the repair takes place.
Are lost profits consequential damages?
Often, yes. Lost profits usually depend on deals outside the contract, so many contracts treat them as consequential. Courts also ask for proof with reasonable certainty, not a guess.
Is a waiver of consequential damages enforceable?
Yes, when the clause is clear and the governing law allows it. For US sales of goods, UCC section 2-719 lets parties exclude consequential damages unless the exclusion is unconscionable. Ask a lawyer about your contract.
Can a business exclude consequential damages for personal injury?
For consumer goods, that is hard to do. UCC section 2-719 treats a limit on personal injury damages as unconscionable at first sight. Other laws set their own rules, so ask a lawyer.
Do I need a lawyer to review a consequential damages clause?
It is wise for any contract with real money at stake. The rules differ by country, state and type of contract, and small wording changes can shift who pays.
Should a consequential damages waiver apply to both parties?
A mutual waiver is common and often easier to agree. Each side gives up the same kind of claim, so neither carries an open-ended risk alone.
Is a contract with a consequential damages clause valid when signed electronically?
Yes, when the signers agree to sign electronically and the record is kept. Each document signed in BoldSign comes with an audit trail of who signed and when.