Who's Liable When an AI Agent Sends the Wrong Contract?
TL;DR: The business that runs an artificial intelligence (AI) agent usually carries the risk when the agent sends the wrong contract. US federal law lets a contract stand when an electronic agent formed it and the agent’s action is attributable to that business. The practical answer is guardrails, such as sending through our Model Context Protocol (MCP) server with locked templates and a full record.
Picture an AI assistant that handles your customer renewals. One afternoon it quotes last year’s discounted price by mistake and sends the renewal for signature. The customer signs within the hour.
Are you held to that price, and whose problem is it? This guide covers what US and EU law say, then the controls that keep an agent’s mistakes small. It is general information, not legal advice, so talk to your counsel about your own case.
What is an electronic agent under US law?
An electronic agent is software that acts on records with nobody checking each step at the time. The federal Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce (ESIGN) Act defines it in section 7006.
The definition covers “a computer program or an electronic or other automated means used independently” to start an action or respond to records. An AI agent that drafts, fills and sends agreements fits that description.
Think of a vending machine. Nobody stands behind it, yet the owner stands behind each sale it makes.
Does an AI agent have authority to bind your business?
Often, yes. Under section 7001(h) of the ESIGN Act, a contract keeps its legal effect even when electronic agents formed it.
The agent’s action must also be “legally attributable to the person to be bound” for this rule to apply. Expect a counterparty to treat the agent’s sends as yours when your business set it up and let it send.
Your counsel decides how attribution works for your facts and your state. Our guide to electronic signature law in the United States covers the wider rules.
What happens when an AI agent sends the wrong contract?
The simplest fix is to cancel the request before anyone signs. After every signer finishes, the problem becomes a legal question for your counsel.
Our API lets your agent or a person revoke a document with a short message explaining why. After that, signers can no longer view or sign it.
Revoking works only while signing is still in progress. Speed matters, so your team needs to learn about a bad send within minutes, not at month-end.
What does the EU AI Act add for AI agents?
The EU AI Act adds a duty to be open about AI. Article 50(1) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 asks providers to design AI systems that talk with people so those people know.
The rule applies unless it is obvious to a well-informed person that they are dealing with AI. The act calls a business that uses an AI system under its own authority a “deployer.”
A chat agent that collects a customer’s details before sending a contract is the kind of system Article 50(1) describes. Check with your counsel which duties fall on you and which fall on your AI provider.
Which guardrails keep an AI agent’s contracts in check?
The law points at the business that runs the agent, so the answer is control and proof. Five guardrails turn that into a working plan.
- Write down which documents the agent may send, to whom, and up to what value.
- Send only from approved templates that the agent cannot rewrite.
- Add a human approval step for high-value or unusual agreements.
- Get an alert for every send, view, signature and decline.
- Keep an audit trail and a tamper-evident seal on every document.
The next section shows how each guardrail maps to a setting in BoldSign.
How does BoldSign support each guardrail?
Each guardrail matches a setting you can turn on today. The sections below go from the template to the final record.
Lock the template the agent uses
Template usage settings let you lock files, fields, recipients and messages. Our guide to template usage controls shows each option.
With those options off, the agent can fill in values, yet the agreement itself stays as you approved it.
Add a person who approves before signing completes
Add a Reviewer role to the template your agent uses. A reviewer approves the document before or after the signer, without signing it.
The template still needs at least one signer role. Add signer identity verification for agreements that need more proof of who signed.
Watch every send as it happens
A webhook is an automatic message one system sends to another the moment something happens. Our webhooks report document events such as sent, viewed, signed, completed, declined and expired.
App-level and account-level webhooks suit different setups. Our guide to BoldSign webhook levels explains how to choose.
Keep the evidence by default
Every completed document gets an audit trail of who sent, viewed and signed it. A cryptographic hash and a tamper-evident seal show any change made after signing.
When a dispute comes, you hand over the record instead of rebuilding events from memory.
Can you see a guardrailed AI agent working?
Yes. Our public demo includes a warranty claim agent that sends through our MCP server.
The demo agent collects details by chat, fills an approved template and asks you to confirm before it sends. A person then signs from the email we send, with no account needed.
After sending, the demo’s tools check status, send reminders and revoke documents. Those are the same moves your own agent needs when something goes wrong.
Which BoldSign plan do you need, and what does it cost?
You can build and test an agent free in the API sandbox. Live sending through the API and webhooks need the Enterprise API plan.
The Enterprise API plan starts at $30 a month and includes 40 envelopes. Each extra envelope costs $0.75. Signer identity verification starts on the Business plan at $15 per user a month, billed yearly.
Locked templates start on the Growth plan at $5 per user a month, billed yearly. Prices are in USD, as listed on our pricing page in November 2026.
Where do you start with a guardrailed AI agreement agent?
Start small: one template, one agent, one reviewer. Then widen what the agent may send as your team gains trust in it.
- Create a free API sandbox account and connect your first agent.
- Book a demo to plan the guardrails for your own agreements.
- Explore BoldSign MCP to see which tools an agent can call.
Sources
- Title 15, section 7001 of the US Code, ESIGN Act, subsection (h), Legal Information Institute
- Title 15, section 7006 of the US Code, ESIGN Act definitions, Legal Information Institute
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, the EU AI Act, Articles 3 and 50, official EU law portal
Frequently asked questions
Is a business bound by a contract its artificial intelligence (AI) agent sent by mistake?
Yes, when the agent's action is legally attributable to the business, in the words of federal law. Whether the mistake lets you undo the deal is a question for your counsel.
What is an electronic agent?
An electronic agent is a computer program or other automated means that acts or responds to records on its own. Nobody reviews each action at the time it happens.
Who is responsible for an AI agent's actions?
In most cases, the business that set the agent up and lets it send. US federal law looks at whether the agent's action can be attributed to that business.
Can I cancel a contract an AI agent sent by mistake?
You can revoke the document while signing is still in progress. Signers then can no longer view or sign it. Once everyone has signed, ask your counsel what options you have.
What does the EU AI Act say about chat agents?
Article 50(1) asks providers to design AI systems that talk with people so those people know they are dealing with AI. The rule applies unless that is already obvious.
How do I stop an AI agent from changing contract terms?
Send from a template with its usage settings locked. You can lock the files, fields, recipients and message, so the agent fills in values without editing the agreement.
Can a person approve a document an AI agent sends?
Yes. Add a Reviewer role to the template. The reviewer approves the document before or after the signer without signing it, and the template still needs one signer role.
Which BoldSign plan do I need for an AI agreement agent?
You can build and test free in the API sandbox. Live sending through the API and webhooks need the Enterprise API plan, from $30 a month with 40 envelopes.