TL;DR: Arbitration is a private process where a neutral arbitrator decides a dispute, and the award is usually final. Litigation is a public court case, and the losing side can usually appeal. The dispute clause you sign decides which one applies, and our audit trail gives you proof of that signature in either forum.
Picture a founder in Singapore who signs a distribution deal with a partner in Brazil. Both sides focus on price and territory, and the dispute clause gets one quick look. Months later, the deal goes wrong and the founder wants to sue.
Then their lawyer points to one line in the contract. It says any dispute will be “finally resolved by arbitration,” so the case goes to a private arbitrator. There is almost no appeal, and the founder agreed to that the day they signed.
This guide explains how arbitration and litigation differ and what to check before you sign. It is general information about US federal law, not legal advice, so ask a lawyer about your own contract.
What is the difference between arbitration and litigation?
Litigation settles a dispute in a public court, with a judge or jury and a right to appeal. Arbitration settles it in private, with an arbitrator the parties chose and an award that is hard to challenge.
Think of a sports match. Litigation is a game in a public league, with set rules, a crowd and a review panel. Arbitration is a game where both teams hire one referee and agree in advance to accept the call.
What is litigation?
Litigation is a lawsuit in a state or federal court. A judge runs the case under the court’s rules, and a judge or jury decides it.
Court records and hearings are usually public, and rulings can guide later cases. A party who loses can ask a higher court to review the decision.
In US federal courts, the courts of appeals hear appeals from final decisions of the district courts under 28 US Code section 1291.
What is arbitration?
Arbitration is a private process that the parties agree to in a contract. One arbitrator or a panel hears the evidence and issues a decision called an award.
The parties can pick the arbitrator, the place, the language and the rules. Many choose an arbitrator who knows their industry. The award usually ends the dispute, and a court can turn it into a judgment that a party can enforce.
How do arbitration and litigation compare?
The two routes differ most in privacy, speed, cost and review. Here is how each one handles those points.
Privacy
In court, filings and hearings are usually open, so anyone can read about the dispute. Arbitration hearings happen in private, and many contracts or rules keep them confidential.
Privacy protects business secrets. The cost is that private awards do not build public case law.
Speed and cost
Court cases move through fixed stages, such as motions, evidence requests, trial and appeal. Each stage can add months. In arbitration, the arbitrator and the parties set the timetable, so there are often fewer steps.
Both routes cost money. In court, each side pays its own lawyers and court fees. In arbitration, the parties also pay the arbitrator and, often, an arbitration body’s fees.
Review after the decision
A court ruling can be appealed when the judge got the law wrong. An arbitration award is built to be final, and courts rarely look at the merits again.
Can you appeal an arbitration award?
In most cases, no. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, a federal court can vacate (set aside) an award only on the grounds in 9 US Code section 10.
- The award came from corruption, fraud or undue means.
- An arbitrator showed clear bias or corruption.
- The arbitrators refused to hear relevant evidence or committed other serious misconduct.
- The arbitrators went beyond their powers or failed to make a final award.
A mistake about the facts or the law is not on that list. To enforce an award, a party can ask a court to confirm it within one year, under 9 US Code section 9.
State law and the law of other countries set their own rules.
Is an arbitration clause in an e-signed contract enforceable?
Yes, when the contract around it is valid. 9 US Code section 2 makes a written arbitration clause in a contract involving commerce “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable.”
The same section keeps the usual defenses that can undo any contract.
Signing electronically does not weaken the clause. The Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN) sits at 15 US Code section 7001. It says a contract cannot be denied legal effect solely because it is in electronic form.
Our guide on how to sign a document online legally covers what that law asks for.
There is one federal exception to know. Under 9 US Code section 402, a person who alleges sexual harassment or sexual assault can choose court. An arbitration clause signed before the dispute cannot force that case into arbitration.
Why do international contracts often choose arbitration?
Parties from different countries often prefer a neutral forum over the other side’s home court. Arbitration lets them pick a place, a language and rules that neither side controls.
Enforcement matters too. The 1958 Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards is known as the New York Convention. It lets a winning party enforce an award abroad, and US courts enforce it under 9 US Code section 201.
A dispute clause works together with the governing law clause. Our guide to governing law and jurisdiction clauses in cross-border contracts explains how to pair them.
What should you check in a dispute clause before you sign?
Read the clause as closely as the price. Once both sides sign, the clause usually binds them, so ask questions during the negotiation.
- Does it say arbitration, litigation or a step before either, such as mediation?
- Which rules apply, and does an arbitration body run the case?
- Where will the hearing take place, and in which language?
- How many arbitrators will there be, and who pays their fees?
- Which country’s or state’s law governs the contract?
For the last question, our guide to governing law vs jurisdiction vs venue shows how each clause picks the law, the court and the place.
How does BoldSign help when a signed contract ends up in a dispute?
Both a judge and an arbitrator will ask who signed the contract and when. Our audit trail answers that, and you get it as one PDF with the signed document.
The record shows who signed and when, plus the device used and how we verified each signer.
That proof travels with the contract, so it is ready for either forum. Our guide to electronic signature evidence for litigation and arbitration explains how to present it.
Ready to send your next contract for signature?
Send a contract with a clear dispute clause and keep the proof of who signed it.
- Start a 30-day free trial and send your first contract today.
- Book a demo to see how signing and audit trails work.
- Contact our support team with questions about your account.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between arbitration and litigation?
Arbitration is a private process where an arbitrator the parties chose decides the dispute. Litigation is a public court case decided by a judge or jury, and the losing side can usually appeal.
How long does arbitration take?
It depends on the case. The parties and the arbitrator set the timetable, which often means fewer steps than a court case has. A complex arbitration can still take a long time.
Can you appeal an arbitration award?
Not on the merits in most cases. Under US federal law, a court can set an award aside only on narrow grounds, such as fraud or an arbitrator who went beyond their powers.
Is an arbitration clause in an e-signed contract enforceable?
Yes, when the contract itself is valid. US federal law treats a written arbitration clause as enforceable, and US e-signature law says a contract cannot be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic.
Are arbitration hearings private?
Usually, yes. Hearings take place outside public court, and many arbitration rules or contracts keep them confidential. A court case is normally open to the public.
Who pays for arbitration?
The parties do. On top of their own lawyers, they pay the arbitrator and often an arbitration body's fees. The contract or the rules it names usually say how those fees are split.
Can I refuse to sign a contract with an arbitration clause?
Yes. You can ask to remove or change the clause before you sign. Once you sign, the clause usually binds you, so raise it during the negotiation.
Why do international contracts often use arbitration?
Arbitration lets parties from different countries pick a neutral place and rules. Awards can be enforced in many countries under the 1958 New York Convention, which US courts apply.